At
Any Rate
by
Bill Harris
Model 4,
May 2002
How Fast Can You Grow? A Strategic Systems
View of Business Growth
Now
that the recession in the United States is technically
over, are our companies poised for growth? How fast
can we grow our businesses? After months of downsizing
and belt-tightening, do we still remember what to do?
Maybe
we should ask a better question: How fast should
we grow our companies so that we really achieve our
goals and create sustainable businesses? We've seen
in the end of the last century and the beginning of
this one that it's possible to grow at astounding rates,
but it's hardvery hardto sustain those rates.
Often,
we become used to dealing with one set of problems (slowdowns,
layoffs) and forget that relief from those problems
(economic growth) has its own set of challenges. While
it will certainly be refreshing to have to deal with
increasing revenues, profits, and staffing, it may be
helpful to look realistically at what we'll face in
the next part of the economic cycle.
To
those of us still suffering from the pain of too little
business, thinking about dealing with growth may seem
like fantasizing about winning the lotteryamusing,
but of little practical use. Yet I suggest that now
is precisely the time to consider more carefully how
fast we want to grow; once growth strikes, we won't
have that luxury. Let's think about this future by considering
the past.
In
1957, David Packard, cofounder of Hewlett-Packard Company,
told attendees at the Seventh Region IRE Conference
how Hewlett-Packard was managing their rapid growth.
He laid great importance on the company's objectives:
focusing on a specific field, putting efforts into making
a true contribution, providing security and opportunity
for employees, and fulfilling its responsibility to
the communities in which it existed.
Crucial
to achieving these objectives, he said, were two more
key goals: growing as rapidly as they could on a pay-as-you-go
basis and earning at least a 10-percent profit each
month. Profit is key to managing growth, because it
not only enables you to provide security and opportunity,
but it allows you to remain independentyou can
fund growth without seeking outside capital. Because
many small companies need such an infusion of outside
capital to sustain their desired growth, they end up
being purchased.
In
this talk, Packard focused on managing growth successfully.
He gave a rule of thumb for the maximum rate a company
could grow and still live within its means (which, for
him, meant self-funding: growth based on profits, not
external investments or loans).
What was his magic formula for growing without losing
financial control? "The percentage increase in sales
which you can finance each year is equal to your percentage
of profit after taxes times your capital turnover. Capital
turnover is defined as the number of dollars in sales
you can produce per year for each dollar of capital
you have invested in your business."

By
this rule, if you want to grow quickly through self-funding,
you need to be sufficiently profitable, you need sufficient
capital turnover (productivity), and you need to reinvest
your profit into your company.
Let's
consider the two factors, profit and capital turnover,
separately. Most of us understand profit percentages:
It's simply the money left over at the end of the year
after paying all the bills (including taxes), divided
by the company's total revenue. Packard's rule of thumb
says that the rate at which you can grow is directly
proportional to your profit percentage: If you increase
your profit percentage by 25 percent, you can grow 25
percent faster. Conversely, if your profits decline
by 25 percent, you should lower your company's growth
rate by that same 25 percent.
Capital
turnover may be less familiar. A company's capital (or
capital assets) consists of the money, equipment, buildings,
and land that it owns to produce goods and services.
In other words, "You need money to make money." Without
money to pay for raw materials or the equipment to assemble
products, you won't be able to build products to sell
to customers. Without sales, you have no revenue (the
money you receive for products and services sold). Capital
turnover describes roughly how many dollars in revenue
you can generate for each dollar invested in the company's
capital assets.
To
figure out your capital turnover, divide your annual
revenue by the total value of your capital assets. To
illustrate how to manage growth using profit and capital
turnover, let's say your company has $2 million in revenue,
$500,000 in capital assets, and earns 10-percent profit
after taxes this year. By Packard's formula, your capital
turnover is 4.0 (2,000,000 divided by 500,000). Your
profit in dollars is 10 percent of $2 million, or $200,000.
At the end of the year, you invest that $200,000 in
the company, raising its capital assets from $500,000
to $700,000. If your capital turnover remains at 4.0,
then you can generate $2.8 million in revenue next year.
That's 40 percent more revenue than this year, the same
result that you get from using Packard's formula: 4.0
times 10 percent. If you try to grow faster than that,
you'll likely find you need external sources of funds
to increase your capital.
Packard
devised this rule of thumb to bound Hewlett-Packard's
growth so the company wouldn't be subject to acquisition
and dilution of the principles he held dear. It should
serve as a useful financial planning tool for others
with a similar goal of sustainable growth.
Of
course, this model only scratches the surface on the
limits to growth of an organization. For a company to
grow, there has to be sufficient demand for the products
or services offered. The company must have the organizational
capacity to grow at the desired rate, including the
ability to hire and train employees and scalable processes
to manage higher volumes. There must be sufficient resources
to build the products. There may be governmentally imposed
limits to your growth because of pollution or traffic
concerns. Finally, you may want to consider whether
your product is needed and how it will help the world
and your shareholders. The financial constraints we've
discussed, as important as they are, are only one of
a number of possible constraints.
How
will you decide how fast you want your company to grow?
Consider first how your long-term goals are affected
(and how they affect) key systems: financial, organizational,
ecological, or whatever makes sense for you. Then create
a rule of thumb that you can use to guide your decisions.
You can explore Packard's ideas more fully by downloading
the model and trying it out. Once you've experienced
the model, share your thoughts in the Pegasus Forum.
"Growth
from Performance," a speech by David Packard, was presented
at the Seventh Region IRE Conference on April 24, 1957.
It is quoted here courtesy and by permission of the
Agilent Technologies Archives and Karen Lewis, Archivist.
Revenue and profit results from 1950 through 1957 are
courtesy of Patricia Parsons at the Agilent Technologies
Archives.

Using
the Model
To use the model, you'll need to download two filesthe
"current model" and the "isee Player"
(the ithink® Runtime for the At Any Rate
model series) that runs the model. Both are located
in the "Get" section toward the top of
the right-hand column. You'll then need to install
the isee Player on your computer. (Once you have
installed the isee Player on your computer, you
no longer have to go through this process unless
the reader is updated.)
1)
Download the "Current Model"
Click "Current Model."
Choose "Save this file to a disk"
and click "okay."
In "Save As," save the ITR file
to your desktop (or to a folder of your choosing).
2)
Download and install the "isee Player"
Follow the instructions on the isee Systems
site.
After
you install the isee Player, to run the model, you
can go to your desktop and double-click on "model1.itr"
or start the ithink® program and use
the "file open" command to locate and
open the model1.itr file.
You are ready to begin. Feel free to play with the
model. We've put more content in it than we've described
in this column. Try different things. If you've
got an interesting idea, a question, or a comment,
go to our Pegasus
Forum. We'd enjoy hearing from you.

This
learning lab was developed using the ithink®
software, a computer simulation modeling
package developed and distributed by isee Systems.
|